You could try for a price beat at Mitre10 in Auckland. Although the product images differ slightly, I was able to get approval through the online form. They only allowed me to purchase two and the nearest store has no stock, so I decided not to proceed. Feel free to try your luck in-store if you're in Auckland.
https://www.mitre10.co.nz/shop/jif-original-cream-cleaner-50…
Lincoln Road, Shopping Centre, Henderson, Auckland 0610